<< Back to Clans Forum   Search

Posts 31 - 50 of 373   <<Prev   1  2  3  ...  10  ...  18  19  Next >>   
Clan League 13: Official Thread: 2020-08-11 13:56:00


Edge 
Level 63
Report
Clan League 13: Official Thread: 2020-08-11 14:50:59

[V.I.W] recruiting time! Join us !
Level 65
Report
you won't play, remember !
Clan League 13: Official Thread: 2020-08-12 13:12:30


(deleted) 
Level 62
Report
His ethics, values and principles will define a man in such life.

As a clan leader of Outlaws, I feel it's best for the sake of the league that Outlaws continue their participation because Community comes first.

I'll defend the league from the MH braggers and send them back to Division B.

May the 50% at strength Outlaws team defeat the M'Hunters in a great relegation battle to end all relegation battles!
Clan League 13: Official Thread: 2020-08-12 22:17:39


Checkmqte
Level 61
Report
@LND - Believe 54 is the level needed for biomes, which is the highest level for any template.
Clan League 13: Official Thread: 2020-08-12 22:35:28


Math Wolf 
Level 64
Report
Question: I see no deadline for sign-ups.

Question: Is the deadline for sign-ups also August 30? This would be a little impractical as dropouts may drastically change the make-up of (especially lower) divisions and teams may want to change their lineup to reflect this.
Clan League 13: Official Thread: 2020-08-12 23:05:07


Farah♦ 
Level 61
Report
Question: Is the deadline for sign-ups also August 30? This would be a little impractical as dropouts may drastically change the make-up of (especially lower) divisions and teams may want to change their lineup to reflect this.

There's always been this thought where you want to determine your lineup based on clans in your division. There are two main arguments against this:
1) It rarely happens, if ever. I've played for multiple clans, in multiple divisions and I've never seen someone even propose a change in roster or lineup because of a certain clan being in their division or them dropping out. If some clan happens to approach their division in this way at all, it can be discarded; it has no impact on the league.
2) If you need to change your lineup based on which changes happen within your division, you might be better off trying to recruit better players to increase your odds of scoring higher. Pro-tip: it's more efficient.

The deadline for sign-ups will remain August 30. The deadline for rosters and lineups will also remain August 30. If a clan fails to submit any of those before the deadline, it's bad luck.
Clan League 13: Official Thread: 2020-08-12 23:33:44


Math Wolf 
Level 64
Report
Alright, clear answer, thank you.
I actually wanted to implicitly also (mainly) refer to the clans that themselves may end up in a higher division, I assume I did not make that clear. For them, the impact is quite large.


I do think you overlook some complexity though:
1) It rarely happens, if ever.

Stats did it, in the qualifiers in their first season in the league, in the form of substitutions after the qualifiers were drawn. (CL9)
It was a brilliant move that ended up paying off massively when they promoted that season.

Full story: that season, there were 3 qualifiers, the top 2 of each qualifier was gathered in C. One qualifier, including Stats, Apprentice and 101st was a lot stronger than the others however. Stats reacted by immediately adding a slot for their stronger players in the Q (at the cost of a slot in C), and finished 2nd in their qualifier with less than a single game difference between them and the 3rd team. An average showing in C was enough to promote thanks to dropouts from B the next season.

Similarly, a clan could motivate its better players to play more slots when they are in a higher division (has certainly been the case for Stats before), or in fact recruit better players when they are in a higher division. I actually did get the question "In which division will you play" several times when recruiting players. (Bad, but relevant example: Nauz in CL11) And it happened to us twice already that we promoted due to dropouts (CL9->CL10 & CL10->CL11, it won't happen this season) So I respectfully disagree that it wouldn't matter, because I do know for a fact that it does matter quite a lot.

And since you have an account in Stats yourself, you are effectively in a clan for which it matters as well. ;-)
Clan League 13: Official Thread: 2020-08-12 23:37:31


ktyne
Level 34
Report
Stats did it, in the qualifiers in their first season in the league, in the form of substitutions after the qualifiers were drawn. (CL9)
"The clan that's really into math and game theory did this" seems like an exception-that-proves-the-rule kind of thing.
Clan League 13: Official Thread: 2020-08-12 23:56:51


LND 
Level 61
Report
Thank you Checkmqte!

Edited 8/12/2020 23:57:30
Clan League 13: Official Thread: 2020-08-13 00:28:48


Master Turtle 
Level 62
Report
We will decide if we are playing on August 29th.
Clan League 13: Official Thread: 2020-08-13 06:17:00

(deleted)
Level 62
Report
@Yaxvi
so if we're having an epic battle. Which clan do you expect to see below us?
Clan League 13: Official Thread: 2020-08-13 09:02:52


Rheumakay
Level 60
Report
@Master Turtle
if you want to make the work as difficult as possible for people working at the CL panel, this is the right move
Clan League 13: Official Thread: 2020-08-13 09:28:10


Farah♦ 
Level 61
Report
I actually wanted to implicitly also (mainly) refer to the clans that themselves may end up in a higher division, I assume I did not make that clear. For them, the impact is quite large.

That's actually true. Let's do it like this. Once the highest division has completely signed up (division A), I'll post it on the forums. This way, nobody in division B can promote to A by dropouts. Once the whole of division B signs up after that, I'll post it to the forums as well, etc. That's about as much as I can do. If you have any better suggestions, feel free to let me know.

And since you have an account in Stats yourself, you are effectively in a clan for which it matters as well. ;-)

Touché, sir.
Clan League 13: Official Thread: 2020-08-13 11:00:57

Rento 
Level 62
Report
Actually, no template requires a level as high as 54.
For China you need 52, for Greece 51 (and neither is played this season). Level 50 suffices for everything else :)
Clan League 13: Official Thread: 2020-08-13 11:47:37


LND 
Level 61
Report
teams may want to change their lineup to reflect this

I may be in over my head here, but appears to me that while this could certainly be the case in a CL with qualifiers, in the current system I'm not sure why this is an issue - wouldn't everyone be playing their top squad regardless of which division they are in? (I mean, some clans might not necessarily need their top squad to win their division, but I would've thought that it's a bit of a risk to take with no real benefits?)
In short, I can't see any reasons under the current system (with no qualifiers) for a change of lineup based on what division you're playing in. But I might be wrong?

Once the highest division has completely signed up (division A), I'll post it on the forums. This way, nobody in division B can promote to A by dropouts.

I therefore don't really see the point in this, though it doesn't do any harm.

Anyway, I'm open to correction if people have noticed something I haven't!

Edited 8/13/2020 11:48:39
Clan League 13: Official Thread: 2020-08-13 13:09:47


ChrisCMU 
Level 61
Report
wg is in. me as contact and reza as backup. i will put links in sheet when on pc today

https://www.warzone.com/Profile?p=999878954

https://www.warzone.com/Profile?p=398976518

Edited 8/14/2020 18:32:56
Clan League 13: Official Thread: 2020-08-13 13:48:37


Farah♦ 
Level 61
Report
Okay, that means that as of now, all clans playing in division A have signed up (despite platinum's promises). Any clan that is in division B should not have to worry anymore that they end up in another division.
Clan League 13: Official Thread: 2020-08-13 14:38:35


Garlikid D. Ven 
Level 60
Report
CORP

Primary contact : Garlikid D. Ven
https://www.warzone.com/Profile?p=6351401628

Secondary contact : dry-clean-only
https://www.warzone.com/Profile?p=4419488318
Clan League 13: Official Thread: 2020-08-13 14:59:50


RecMart 
Level 64
Report
Clan League 13: Official Thread: 2020-08-13 15:39:08


(deleted) 
Level 62
Report
WG of course @Emu Pub

FCC can be the surprise package of the season (there's always one).
Posts 31 - 50 of 373   <<Prev   1  2  3  ...  10  ...  18  19  Next >>