<< Back to Clans Forum   Search

Posts 1 - 30 of 48   1  2  Next >>   
Proposition: Clan League Players Association?: 4/11/2020 01:07:54


{TLA} LND
Level 58
Report
First, before you bite, this is purely an idea, and it's not trying to take power from current CL governing bodies.
As I see it, this would be made up of one representative from each clan in CL (clan manager or otherwise) and would basically discuss any issues regarding CL, and then would vote on it. The results of these deliberations would be made available to the CL governing bodies for their use in making decisions. Think of it as the conscience of CL - has no real power, but can tell you if you're perhaps not doing things right.
I don't know, just an idea I had. Let me know your thoughts (politely and respectfully please!) and any alterations to the idea if you think any are necessary.
Proposition: Clan League Players Association?: 4/11/2020 01:18:58


Rikku
Level 61
Report
What about feeder clans that can voice their opinion twice seems like it would bias the so called CL conscious.
Proposition: Clan League Players Association?: 4/11/2020 01:52:19


Cowboy 
Level 60
Report
Nothing would ever get done. Even with a panel of 5 agreeing on everything has not been easy.
Proposition: Clan League Players Association?: 4/11/2020 01:53:48


Xenophon 
Level 63
Report
I shotgun being president of the clan league players association
Proposition: Clan League Players Association?: 4/11/2020 01:54:21


Aura Guardian 
Level 62
Report
Nothing productive would ever get done.

We already have something like that in place. Sometimes we get together on ground breaking changes and do representative voting by clans. But every time that happens its a nightmare.

Edited 4/11/2020 01:57:02
Proposition: Clan League Players Association?: 4/11/2020 02:12:26


{TLA} LND
Level 58
Report
What about feeder clans that can voice their opinion twice seems like it would bias the so called CL conscious.

Not quite sure what you meant by this.
We already have something like that in place.

I thought there might be something, I should have asked. I'd be interested to see the details!
Also, I know things aren't likely to get done, however I was thinking a simple vote with a time limit on it would at least do something. But yeah, keep letting me know if you think it is at all useful - I think that would be the key point: would it achieve anything? I think some of you are saying no already, anyone else?
Proposition: Clan League Players Association?: 4/11/2020 02:17:48


Wartortle
Level 54
Report
Turtle's need representation.
- downvoted post by Battle Master ⚔
- downvoted post by L
Proposition: Clan League Players Association?: 4/11/2020 07:10:01


Cowboy 
Level 60
Report
Yes, it's because of the power and because of the headache running a mess of a clan league where everyone is trying to get their hands in the pot.
Proposition: Clan League Players Association?: 4/11/2020 07:56:09


lineal2012
Level 60
Report
I am against, I like the way Clan League is govern.
- downvoted post by goralgn
- downvoted post by goralgn
Proposition: Clan League Players Association?: 4/11/2020 09:04:36


{TLA} LND
Level 58
Report
I like the way Clan League is govern.

This isn't changing government, just potentially advising it. But if you think differently, please explain. ;)
- downvoted post by goralgn
Proposition: Clan League Players Association?: 4/11/2020 09:24:20


Farah♦ 
Level 61
Report
It's a quote. Use the quote tags
- downvoted post by goralgn
Proposition: Clan League Players Association?: 4/11/2020 09:52:53


krunx 
Level 63
Report
This already took place and we have such a association already.

Why don't you just play a CL season before you suggest stuff? Latly I read a ton of stuff about CL by people who are not even really involved.

Don't know the format, the rules etc., but comment on stuff with a strong opinion. Just participate and then suggest adjustments. It is not like such stuff isn't taken into consideration, but suggesting stuff while knowing little to nothing won't help anyone
- downvoted post by goralgn
- downvoted post by goralgn
- downvoted post by goralgn
Proposition: Clan League Players Association?: 4/11/2020 10:42:16


Farah♦ 
Level 61
Report
And why cant someone voice an opinion if they didnt join the clan league simple you believe they dont deserve it


i believe you need outside advice because they mostly believe in what they say without The Cl being a factor


Because the people who have played CL are familiair with the format, the rules, the promotion/relegation system etcetera. It's not that they don't deserve to voice an opinion, it's just that it's extremely likely that what they're voicing has long been considered by the organizing and playing parties.
Proposition: Clan League Players Association?: 4/11/2020 11:05:36


goralgn
Level 55
Report
ok i admit i was wrong


Now can we discuss the actual topic?

Edited 4/11/2020 11:16:28
Proposition: Clan League Players Association?: 4/11/2020 12:20:46


{TLA} LND
Level 58
Report
This already took place and we have such a association already.

Why don't you just play a CL season before you suggest stuff? Latly I read a ton of stuff about CL by people who are not even really involved.

Don't know the format, the rules etc., but comment on stuff with a strong opinion. Just participate and then suggest adjustments. It is not like such stuff isn't taken into consideration, but suggesting stuff while knowing little to nothing won't help anyone

1. If there is such an association how come newcomers to CL this year are not invited to it? A couple people have mentioned it, however I have seen no evidence of this (though I'd be happy for you to change this!). What's the point of a players' association if it's not available to players?
2. I've pretty much just finished my first season of CL, so while I haven't been for long I'm definitely involved.
3. Yes, I'm still getting the hang of the format/rules, but I try not to comment with a strong opinion unless I have had things explained to me. The original post in this thread is anything but a strong opinion; rather, a tentative suggestion.
Proposition: Clan League Players Association?: 4/11/2020 14:59:09


Checkmqte
Level 60
Report
1. If there is such an association how come newcomers to CL this year are not invited to it? A couple people have mentioned it, however I have seen no evidence of this (though I'd be happy for you to change this!). What's the point of a players' association if it's not available to players?


The last vote I remember was at the start of this season about how CL templates would be chosen and if that process would be changed. That vote included only clans that had played in CL 11 and were signed up for CL 12, if I recall correctly. If there's a new vote before/during next CL, and TLA doesn't drop out, they would likely be included in that vote.
Proposition: Clan League Players Association?: 4/11/2020 17:55:35


goralgn
Level 55
Report
"The last vote I remember was at the start of this season about how CL templates would be chosen and if that process would be changed. That vote included only clans that had played in CL 11 and were signed up for CL 12, if I recall correctly. If there's a new vote before/during next CL, and TLA doesn't drop out, they would likely be included in that vote."


what you mean basically newcomers didnt get a say in what maps they are gonna play?
- downvoted post by Battle Master ⚔
Proposition: Clan League Players Association?: 4/11/2020 18:03:20


goralgn
Level 55
Report
"slagi, ngl"

what does this mean?
Proposition: Clan League Players Association?: 4/11/2020 18:03:53


JK_3 
Level 60
Report
Just ignore BM, he has been spamming various forum threads with BS out of boredom today

https://imgur.com/a/hwlztrN

Edited 4/11/2020 18:07:53
Proposition: Clan League Players Association?: 4/11/2020 18:04:08


Battle Master ⚔
Level 57
Report
seems like a good idea, not gonna lie
Posts 1 - 30 of 48   1  2  Next >>