I'm gonna do another rundown of my thoughts but first I just want to say that all the villagers who are playing so not to rouse suspicion on themselves are missing the point of this game.
Ace Windu - for second round logical votes. Right about bdh. Doesn't agree with tactical. Village. Apollo - you asked somewhere if something is game related? Everything is. Not much info. Voted hhh. Village??? C-17 - got to go. Second round completely useless. Clavicus Vile - voted hhh. Noted Eliza weirdness. Noted bdh and silver may be both villagers. Should look at quiet ones. Village? Coaleyes - okay. Good villager. Keep around. What was the silencing all about? Thinks skunk is village. Dr. Stupid - was wrong but logical and hunting. New theory is good. Village. Eliza - hypocrite. Voted hhh for inactivity. Got to go. Frankdeslimste - notes how useless hhh votes are. Village??? Not much info. G. Arun - agrees with JSA . bandwagoning despite saying he doesn't want to. Self preservation. Wolf??? If you agree with the wagon join it and say why. Genghis - abstained. Notes Arun gnuff and tactical block voters. Village? Gnuffone - all over the bandwagon like a rash. Would expect him to be far more vocal if wolf hunting. He doesnt usually mince his words. Wolf?? Heyheuhei - got to go. Worst type of forummer for this game. Could be anything. We know he never says much. I'd be happy to vote hhh. JSA - voted bdh after silver. Suspects clavicus and Apollo who I Dont much. But he claims IDIOT and got skunk as villager. I believe him as was talking about chances of being seer on p10 and seeding skunk tells a believable story. Are you sure you are not just a seer? Kantos - avoids bandwagon so obviously with random c17 vote. Then makes sure world knows he was right that silver might be village. Wolf?? Kasparov - votes clavicus believing hes trying to out a special. I Dont understand. ? Lawlz - votes hhh. mixing it up. Village. Lord Veigar - MIA? Got to go MoD - missed lynch.finally comes in with sensible suggestion that the wolves killed rento to raise suspicion on timi. Village? rento - obsessed with timi to the end. I don't get it. Was seer. Silver - I think was clearly village. Shouldnt have been shot. Ska2D2 - voted tactical incursion. Called out arun on bandwagoning. Village? skunk940 - apparently 40 % likely to be wolf. Thought rento was wolf. I feel he is different this game. At start talking about randoming. Wolf????? Tactical Incursion - attacked clav after reasonable vote. Why Dont you suspect Eliza? Voted bdh. Wolf????? Timinator - good hunter. Apparently sikver got evidence he is village? And we know how bloodthirsty silver can be/ No idea what that could be but it sounds believable. Voted hhh Village?
Just say who you will silence skunk and Dom will tell us who's silenced. It doesn't matter who you silence. I will believe you unless there is a counter claim though.
My top picks for wolf are here - in order. Gnuff Kantos Arun Tactical incursion Eliza Skunk - that claim makes me very unsure here though.
These two I'd be happy to lynch too. But secondary. Veigar Hhh
Don't have much time to go into it at the moment, but i'd suggest keeping an eye on those pack voters who are now willing to vote out Skunk or other confirmed wolves. Pack-voting is also going to be much more risky for them now also, so we need to watch for those going inactive and making useless outside votes.
I agree with the suspicion on Gnuffone, after he jumped on the Skunk thing I was thinking it looked just like he was trying to save himself from the previous voting.
Gnuffone, Tactical Incursion, Eliza, Ska JSA possibly Timinator
The wolves are clearly pretty skilled at the game so we should be looking at some of the better players, which is why I listed Ska, JSA and Timinator. I have a hunch that those three are up to something. Timinator is pretty defensive in his actions, JSA seems iffy and Ska... well I don't know.
Only the top 3 are suspects with more substantial reasoning
I doubt its Skunk, seeing as he's silenced Arun like he was going to. But that's not 100%. He's been suspicious on one or two occasions, but so have others.
Gnuff doesn't really get involved to much, but that gives two sides. Either he's playing the hiding game and doesn't want to make himself look too suspicious or of course external (inactivity, busy etc). I'm still weighing up the options.
I guess he meant players that contribute the most and the players that are most helpful. It doesn't have a link to skill.
Skunk generally seems sensible when he plays this game. I'd consider a Gnuff vote, but I'm still worried about Tactical - I'd like to know more about why you think Gnuff?
and Ska... well I don't know.
I actually quite like that Clavicus :)
People can see how I act though, how I talk and such like, if you think my thoughts are suspicious you should put them in public for people to consider that. It's best that the village considers everyone because ... well anyone could be a Wolf!
But if we're talking about 'better players' at this sort of thing you should take down the [rp] tag ;)
You fellows are known for being good at characters :p - That's cheeky I know but So it goes. ;)
Timi seems very villagey to me, I don't want him lynched. My top pick would be Tactical Incursion for advocating a multikill and for going after Timi who is hunting as much as anyone.
HHH, Lord Veigar and C-17 are all about the same but I would go for HHH first because he has at least been clearly watching the thread but not posting. Lord Veigar has contributed somewhat in other games so he hopefully he will get more involved and C-17 is an unknown quantity.
Gnuff's seems similar to the last game where he was a wolf, jumping on wagons constantly, although JSA's percentages were pretty convincing so I'm giving him the benefit of the doubt.
There are players that have shown far more than the listed three at wolves. Skunk is a good example. Skunk silenced Arun to prove he's the eldar. If any other eldar is so stupid as to silence Arun immediately after skunk said he would then we are fighting a losing battle. We have to trust that.
Gnuff didn't get involved in the other game he played and he was a wolf. Behind the scenes he was involved though. I bet they are all over a Skype chat. If gnuff was village he would be here with many theories I'm sure.
Apollo don't put yourself on my suspects list defending gnuff or keeping skunk a suspect.
Kantos I would be reasonably happy with that spread of votes. We would maybe see some fight from them.
