<< Back to General Forum   Search

Posts 1 - 30 of 44   1  2  Next >>   
New Warzone Design Finalists: 12/8/2017 18:37:31

Fizzer 
Level 59

Warzone Creator
Report
Hello all!

Here are the top voted entries from the previous design thread ( https://www.warzone.com/Forum/288404-new-warzone-design-megathread )

First place: Louis


Second place: pb45


Third place: Brill


I appreciate all the feedback! I quite like the highest voted entry as well.

To those asking for the ability to switch between multiple designs: Right now my goal is to get one good design implemented. This is a must-do, for obvious reasons -- most users will stick with the default, so having a good default design is important. Adding alternative design is something I can do but it's a secondary feature, and therefore should be an item on uservoice and if it gets more demand than other features it can justify me spending time on it. I don't consider myself a skilled designer, so it actually takes me a lot of time and effort to implement a design.

Edited 12/8/2017 19:31:08
New Warzone Design Finalists: 12/8/2017 19:29:44

TBest 
Level 60
Report
Firstly, all three of them look good!

That being said, I don't like the bacground for pb45, as all the lines don't really matches the connections for a WZ map. It also *feels* like pb45 has some elements that by them self are good, but don't work to well together. (Both 'Play' buttons are kinda just placed in empty space, and don't give a sense of a holistic design)

Both Louis and Brill looks very completed. I really like the top header for Brill and how that is also matching the footer. For me through, the best of these 3 is the first one, Louis. Mostly because WarLight 2 fits right into that logo. Compered to the other two, where WarLight 2 *feels* out of place.

For multiple designs: at least I, mostly means multiple themes rather then designs. That means that the buttons etc. are all in the same place. Only colors/backgrounds would change. That being said, yes do implement one good one first, then let it be a uservoice thing.

TL:DR
1. Louis (Best Logo)
2. Brill (Best Footer/Header)
3. pb45 (I see what it's trying to do, good idea but not really working here)

Edited 12/8/2017 19:33:53
New Warzone Design Finalists: 12/8/2017 19:34:45


master of desaster 
Level 65
Report
1. Louis
2. Brill
3. pb45
New Warzone Design Finalists: 12/8/2017 19:44:16


knyte 
Level 58
Report
1. Louis
2. Brill (can we get rid of the "Fizzer" tab? It seems a bit egotistical tbh)
3. pb45
New Warzone Design Finalists: 12/8/2017 19:44:29


system0101 
Level 55
Report
Louis. Brill with Louis' "Warlight 2" would be the best though.
New Warzone Design Finalists: 12/8/2017 19:47:59


INSIDE 
Level 61
Report
1. Louis
2. Brill
3. pb45

Would be nice to see how Louis looks with a play now button that doesn't have rounded corners.
New Warzone Design Finalists: 12/8/2017 20:04:03


MightySpeck (a Koala) 
Level 58
Report
is there some way i could load the designs to my browser so i could see what the whole site feels like. since if for one never use the home page /shurg
New Warzone Design Finalists: 12/8/2017 20:09:18


vicnus 
Level 62
Report
1. Brill
2. Louis
3. pb45



Thanks Fizzer!
New Warzone Design Finalists: 12/8/2017 20:13:23

daftpunk
Level 57
Report
1. Louis
2. pb45
3. Brill
New Warzone Design Finalists: 12/8/2017 20:19:40


Tito 
Level 55
Report
1. pb45
2. louis
3. brill

i think louis will win though, it resembles the warlight design and feels like a loyal upgrade
New Warzone Design Finalists: 12/8/2017 20:22:49

kevin#1 
Level 59
Report
1. Louis
2. Brill
3. pb45

great finalists
New Warzone Design Finalists: 12/8/2017 20:31:00


tomjh
Level 58
Report
Pb45
Louis
Brill
New Warzone Design Finalists: 12/8/2017 20:31:25


NecessaryEagle 
Level 57
Report
1. Brill
2. pb45
3. Louis
New Warzone Design Finalists: 12/8/2017 20:41:15


OnlyThePie
Level 53
Report
I personally think they're all ugly, but Louis is the least ugly, and then Brill
New Warzone Design Finalists: 12/8/2017 20:46:25


Cloud Strife
Level 60
Report
Louis.
New Warzone Design Finalists: 12/8/2017 21:06:18


dabo1 
Level 56
Report
1.Louis
2.Pb45
3.Brill
New Warzone Design Finalists: 12/8/2017 21:18:03


Onoma94 
Level 60
Report
Brill is my favourite here. I like the "militaristic" "steel" look of it, fitting the name. Louis' is aesthetic and tidy too.
New Warzone Design Finalists: 12/8/2017 21:35:30


The Endless Zero
Level 56
Report
1. Louis
2. Pb45
3. Brill
New Warzone Design Finalists: 12/8/2017 21:38:47


#Master [QB] 
Level 62
Report
Louis!
New Warzone Design Finalists: 12/8/2017 21:48:45


Master Shinra
Level 59
Report
Louis.
New Warzone Design Finalists: 12/8/2017 22:59:24


DanWL 
Level 62
Report

    1) Louis
    2) pb45
    3) Brill
New Warzone Design Finalists: 12/9/2017 00:24:30


Dutch Desire
Level 59
Report
1. Brill
2. pb45
3. Louis

Louis is too dark.

Edited 12/9/2017 00:25:48
New Warzone Design Finalists: 12/9/2017 00:45:08


Cata Cauda
Level 59
Report
Louis.
New Warzone Design Finalists: 12/9/2017 02:58:09


TheRiverStyxie 
Level 60
Report
1) Louis
2) pb45
3) Brill
New Warzone Design Finalists: 12/9/2017 04:04:20


Wally Balls 
Level 59
Report
Louis please, or the 2nd one. Not the 3rd.

Generally: just please bring the design into 2017. It looks dated af.
New Warzone Design Finalists: 12/9/2017 04:06:54


Wally Balls 
Level 59
Report
More important than a mockup of the landing page is how all the other pages will look, how it will look across devices and browser sizes, all of buttons and other stuff.

This goes along with bringing the design into 2017. You don't base everything off of a PSD anymore. It's about what it's like actually using it. The designer needs to be deeply involved in every part of the interface, not just give you some pretty colors and fonts to replace the existing ones with.
New Warzone Design Finalists: 12/9/2017 04:10:45


MrTrolldemort 
Level 56
Report
Awesome all the ones I wanted were in the finalists :D

1. Louis

2. pb45

3. Brill

Looking forward to the changes Fizzer
New Warzone Design Finalists: 12/9/2017 08:21:12


Edge
Level 62
Report
1. Louis
2. Brill
3. pb45
New Warzone Design Finalists: 12/9/2017 09:14:05

TheUberElite
Level 40
Report
"(can we get rid of the "Fizzer" tab? It seems a bit egotistical tbh)"

I'd prefer it stay, it's an easy way to see at a glance what account is logged in.
New Warzone Design Finalists: 12/9/2017 09:47:03


aoc
Level 59
Report
1. pb45
2. Louis (its very close and they are both very good)

3. after a big gap Brill
Posts 1 - 30 of 44   1  2  Next >>