I think it would be nice if the supplier of army- and money requests would get an reward for this.
My suggestion is 1AP or 3 BPs or something like this.

excellent idea, Kalr! Totally support it!

support!

+1

+1

Kind of ruins the generosity part of giving and makes it all about self-interest.

It came be both. It 'ruins' nothing at all. The receiver still gets the gift.

Minimally, there should be Achievement... gift 100 times or something.

Please dont add another idle achievement, there are already so many I'm struggling to get....

@Cromwell: It doesnt ruin the generosity, because the reward is low enough. You would be way better of just using those armies for yourself and finishing your level quicker than gifting them away (if you convert it to AP/day). Same would apply for BP, but giving BP makes little sense...

Sorry to be negative, but I think giving is about giving, not receiving something back.

"One needs to learn how to give presents, but also how to receive them"
Henry VIII to Anne Boleyn, shortly before he gave her the axe

It will make people who don't have lots of active Idle clanmates (e.g. me) feel lonely though. On average there's a clan request in my clan once or twice per week. And of course it's always me to fill it.

Maybe a gifting leaderboard within each clan?

Tbh I'd just be happy with Partial clan gift fulfillment.

Don't have the full 5B armies, can only give 1B? Fine, give 1B, leave the 4B for someone else.

I considered upgrading 'Increased Clan Request Sizes' but then figured, if they are 300% larger, probably no one will be able to fulfill them until they're at the exact end of level with armies left over.

Or what about a clan - warchest, say 5% of armies at the end of the run go into the clan chest ,that we could all pull from - could have them slowly atrophy to promote activity.

Then we could actually fill those increased clan req...

Great idea.

Kind of ruins the generosity part of giving and makes it all about self-interest.

Sorry to be negative, but I think giving is about giving, not receiving something back.

I absolutley respect your point of view but I think a game with 'war' in its name is not supposed to be a jesus-simulator.

Please dont add another idle achievement, there are already so many I'm struggling to get....

Sure JK, let's hold off adding new stuff to the game b/c you're struggling finishing off the existing items. yawhuh