I was going to talk about how I was going to vote for RA's map but then I remembered the other thread but then I read knyte's post
Was going to vote for World of Earthsea by RA, but then I saw this: [u89EAEKyJmfQNy5L=https://www.warlight.net/Forum/100790-ra-stolen-strategic-europe-map-europe-30
Legit not even kidding lol it's funny
Anywho, I voted Four Castles. Atlantic isn't a practical map for anything but Bordered-Off Diplomacy (When you are confined to certain areas by huge army blockades via custom scenario), and it does do this very well because its territories are very well proportioned for such a thing.
However, Four Castles is one of the funnest and best strategic maps out there. It sure is hard to play 1v1's on though.