Prove Coaleyes is a villager and wasn't a doppelganger turned troublemaker who made a simple mistake when writing the first post, skunk.

sorry...*is a minion.

I saw when I robbed , train as villager. Therefore I'm villager.
I'm I'm the robber then his balls swaped me and train does that mean train the the robber?

Crisscross.

Edited 2015-06-21 08:55:14

Was a bit busy yesterday sorry. Skunk, if coal eyes is lying who's the doppleganger?

https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1-Ykyt_FAImHvpuvMFUm3dmhehZlAFRHX3WKG8U0MC_4/edit?usp=docslist_api

The 3 highest ranking people on suspiciousness

Apollo
Forbidden Knowledge
Coalyeyes

Edited 2015-06-21 09:00:10

You missed skunk.

Forbidden knowledge wants to die.forget him.

I believe coaleyes.

So?

Apollo
Coaleyes?

Skunk and Me then, I would think that I am the Hunter, I cant see anyother option. Is Myhand a confirmed villager? I don't think Forbidden Knowlegde should be ruled out.

If I had to vote now, it would be on Skunk. Making so many accusations is a good attempt of trying to convince your not a wolf I guess. Which makes you look like your not playing safe.

The wolf is one of Apollo skunk and myhand. Or anice gambit from FK. We know that.

Myhand is not confirmed, no.

Why do you think you are the hunter Apollo?

WpThe seer needs to check FK , if he is a hunter or tanner

what we should do is go back and think what roles are out their that are not specific/unclaimed.

3 villagers
1 Hunter (appears villager)
1 Tanner
2 Wolves (Although FK claims to be 1)
1 Drunk
1 Minion

We know one villager and one wolf was in the 3 unclaimed cards
We do not know the third card
We know there must be one "Bad card" out so to speak assuming Ace is correct.

However we only know what cards are out there by what the other roles have said.

So we have to presume quite a few things:

1) No claimed roles are lying
2) The drunk was not in play (however I believe he was)
3) That at least one "bad role" is still in the unclaimed cards (I think both wolves are in the unclaimed cards)

So with that I believe we are;

1)looking for a Minion
2)looking for a Drunk, Hunter, Tanner and two villagers

These two sum us up to the 5 villager claims we have had and FK who could be anything.

However this can only be made from the 3 assumptions above.

And basing on that I think:

1) Skunk was the drunk
2)FK is betting on being a villager special
3) Apollo is the Tanner trying to be lynched as a Hunter

Should we not go for Apollo?

https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1-Ykyt_FAImHvpuvMFUm3dmhehZlAFRHX3WKG8U0MC_4/edit?usp=docslist_api

We need to check out skunk

I cant prove that Coaleyes is a minion but neither can you prove she isn't.

@Fan The problem is do you want to be responsible for a village win or loss?


Everything is guesswork.

I guess your right . However this the first day. So this is where the most guesses happen. It would get less plausible later on.

Edited 2015-06-21 10:29:19

@Fan no editing

And there is only ONE day

Are you using bribery not to get yourself killed? Yourtalking weird recently

I don't accuse you or anthing , nothing personal

Typo edited

Edited 2015-06-21 10:37:02

I'm just trying to work out if you understand that there is only one day so the game ends at 8pm GMT.


Therefore voting does matter alot.