as promised, here my daily morning rant. yes, i got many complaints for many more mornings.

TL;DR CW rewards suck. in every which way.

Ok, so you think that the CW rewards suck. What kind of rewards would you like to see?

more specifically:
1. CW rewards are way too small. in relation to effort required
2. why only coins for ranks 1-9?
3. reward caches are a bad joke, at best. an insult, at worst

cw structure heavily favors large clans, 40 players, and even more so especially uncapped clans.

CW is a good idea. implementation needs major improvements. Fizzer, wake up and do it!

more ranting tomorrow morning. topic: CW slots & templates in them. stay tuned.

now go ahead and start downvoting my posts. or giving me life advice, "l4v.r0v style".

fya. over and out

for the first 10 clans the reeard isnt that bad

I completely agree! Drop the requirement that you need at least 1 win per season! It is so much effort and favors the elite players from elite clans. This is absolutely unfair. And if we are already on it.. Drop the requirement to be in the clan to get clan wars rewards. I consider it very unfair to not get the MB rewards only because I am not in MB!!

Completely agree. The CW rewards system is exploited by those huge uncapped clans, who mass people every single day and squading the CW slots. If we officially get rid of those clans, then even a small clan like FTW!, Prime or Cats would be able to get their share of CW rewards.

That's my suggested list of clans for deletion or ban from CW:

• Myth Busters
• The Blue Devils
• Optimum
• Mothership
• Harmony
• The Last Alliance
• M'Hunters

Please, if you represent any of those clans, stay away from commenting this post. Obviously you are biased. Please think about community benefits.

That's some impressive dishonesty you've got going there FiveSmith.

But more seriously, I wonder if there is a good scheme, by which the larger clans could have a modest and well deserved advantage, without screwing over the smaller clans?

Idea #1:
Improving the low territory count rewards while reducing the high territory count and high placing rewards would do this. Benefits would be more of a threshold effect, that a few dedicatd ppl could manage even in a small clan.

Idea #2
"Effective Wins" for a clan could be a calcuatlation. Eg: best 10 players in clan get full count, next ten 1/2, next 10 1/3 etc.
Then higher counts would be worth something, but wouldn't dominates quite so much.

Edited 3/5/2023 09:05:50

I support your proposal 5s, ban all successful clans, ban all elite players.

CW should give rewards only to weak players. It's 2023. We need player equity. The competition really shouldn't even be about # of wins anyhow, this is obviously skewed towards skilled players. "Skill privilege". It's not even remotely fair to us weaker players.

The clan with the most FWs in a given season should get 1st place.

otto has a point as well. Many schools have adopted this policy, too ... all participants get a 1st place award b/c it's the participation that counts, not the results. All players that get at least 1 FW per season should get 1st place.

Edited 3/5/2023 09:11:23

Prime should be banned too, they are also too succesful. At least more than Mothership, Harmony and TLA

Edited 3/5/2023 10:33:51

FC Bayern tournaments have better rewards, maybe you should join them instead :)

he is just angry bc FTW was only place 11 last season

That would require him to actually win a game properly instead of eploiting free wins or getting gifted a wins by Good News.

Ignoring Idle boosts.
CW is competitive. That is the problem. Make the difference between the top and bottom places small, people won't try that hard. Make the difference big, bottom rewards will be too small.
Either give individual rewards or drop rewards for ranking.

Of course the worst part of CW is broken matchmaking.