<< Back to Clans Forum   Search

Posts 1 - 20 of 43   1  2  3  Next >>   
A bold new suggestion about Clan Wars: 9/15/2021 05:04:55


καλλιστηι
Level 60
Report
Instead of focusing on suggestions/ updates which would make new players join CW, focus on suggestions/ updates which would make people already playing CW want to keep playing it.

Let me start:

1) change the 40 player limit to 40 wins limit/ day. This will lead to more games, clans with the cap will have a chance, active clans get an advantage and having really good players in the clan becomes less needed.

2) add a personal rating to players in clans, so games are more balanced.

3) CW are currently mostly played by "strategic community". Hence make two types of templates in a slot: one with templates from the current roster (minus FB and Guiroma) and one with templates from a roster chosen by TOP N clans based on rating. Every slot would have at least one template from both rosters, eventually more if in the past many people play a template from the given roster at the given slot.

4) if a player leaves a clan, he can represent another clan after 3 days CD.


Edit: Tarnation grammar

Edited 9/15/2021 13:49:02
A bold new suggestion about Clan Wars: 9/15/2021 10:16:24


Sephiroth
Level 61
Report
A bold new suggestion about Clan Wars: 9/15/2021 10:26:43


inxs
Level 55
Report
@Kallisti
fully agree with your suggestion
#1 40 wins/day limit and
#2 more balanced game matches based on player rating

instead of #3 my suggestions are:
* 3 templates (minimum) for every timeslot. 1 of the 3 templates to always be SE1W (fixed, every timeslot). It is the map vast majority of active players wants to play and has time for. Why deny it and force weirdo maps on us?
* Eliminate SEAD (too luck based) and SECB (games often too long) from CW
* Other 2 templates per timeslot to be determined according to your suggestion #3 - out of roster determined via voting system.

#4 - No. Players shall only be able to fight for 1 clan per season (as is, no change). CW is a clan event. Clan fights, clan gets rewards. Players should be able to stick with 1 clan for duration of a single CW season. No need to reward poaching and all sorts of similar scheming during an active CW season.

Edited 9/15/2021 10:27:41
A bold new suggestion about Clan Wars: 9/15/2021 10:30:22


JK_3 
Level 61
Report
Eliminate SEAD (too luck based) and SECB (games often too long) from CW

SECB is fine, it just needs a 1,5+2 minute boot timer instead of 3+5
A bold new suggestion about Clan Wars: 9/15/2021 12:15:43


καλλιστηι
Level 60
Report
The thing with clan change is, that some players join not!CW clan and when they join a clan that does CW, they have to wait, even several weeks.
A bold new suggestion about Clan Wars: 9/15/2021 12:16:03


Platinum 
Level 62
Report
I don't understand why a game creator would launch a new event and yet not bother to respond to some feedback/improvement suggestions.

Is he really so stubborn to believe his thought process is always more important than the players that actually play this game?

Knyte's statistical analysis gets more responses than this. Embarrassing.
A bold new suggestion about Clan Wars: 9/15/2021 12:22:01


Ursus 
Level 64
Report

Fizzer fix your shit. You deny new clans the chance to participate in a normal way

Edited 9/15/2021 12:28:24
A bold new suggestion about Clan Wars: 9/15/2021 12:26:43


JK_3 
Level 61
Report
I remember when TLA had that problem, its really annoying.

Especially since with just 1 or 2 (free) wins per timeslot, it also takes ages for the clan rating to reach anything that gets you games.

EDIT:
-- deleted --

Edited 9/15/2021 12:28:57
A bold new suggestion about Clan Wars: 9/15/2021 12:28:59

Cicero_
Level 56
Report
agree with ursus, you guys can make a war between the 2 biggest clans and it will be the same game actually. it is ridiculous.
A bold new suggestion about Clan Wars: 9/15/2021 12:30:08

Baron 2
Level 6
Report
I too agree with Ursus. #Get Rid of Clan Wars rating
A bold new suggestion about Clan Wars: 9/15/2021 12:31:08


Tac(ky)tical
Level 62
Report
+1
A bold new suggestion about Clan Wars: 9/15/2021 12:31:36

Mylo 
Level 61
Report
There are no new suggestions here from καλλιστηι.

Fizzer has responded to can size/how to count wins or games in the past, he doesn't repeat himself.

Templates are exactly what Fizzer wants. He wants people to learn to play QM templates, he wants people in QM.

SECB is a fast template. Usually <10 turns
SEAD is luck based to a degree, but so are a lot of SE1W games on 1st pick, when you play with a 1min clock.
Good SE1W games can last longer than bomber and are often killed by the auto commit
Why would Fizzer add more strategic community templates when Gurioma and FB have been ignored for 4 months of CW?
Why would Fizzer always have an SE when he wants the players to explore all the QM templates.


Disappointing response from you Plat. Maybe search the forums and read over the previous threads. You could also check the times, it's been 10pm-5am for Fizzer to respond to this thread. He is human, not ai

Shall we go over match making again too? and free wins?
A bold new suggestion about Clan Wars: 9/15/2021 12:35:34


Ursus 
Level 64
Report
Maybe there's something wrong with some QM-templates if no one wants to play them and forcing does not work btw... Many people just don't play when they only see MME MALD and MME CLD
I agree SECB should get shorter boot time, I also think every slot should have either SEAD or SE1W for the casuals.
A bold new suggestion about Clan Wars: 9/15/2021 12:38:34


Sephiroth
Level 61
Report
Fizzer fix your shit.

I guess that's exactly what he's doing right now: trying to fix the mess he put himself into when he tried to scam Activision
A bold new suggestion about Clan Wars: 9/15/2021 12:42:59


The Forbidden Koala
Level 60
Report
SEAD have some luck based games, so does SE1W, where 1st pick wins game.
It is also most populated, because its simple and one of first QM templates. I don't see any reason to alienate most on CW community.
A bold new suggestion about Clan Wars: 9/15/2021 12:43:31


ohhhesocute(づ。 ‿‿ 。)づ
Level 55
Report
main problem here is the fact that 15 people from 1 clan joined a time slot and 0 of them got a game. ?????


edit: unjust!

Edited 9/15/2021 12:55:13
A bold new suggestion about Clan Wars: 9/15/2021 12:45:50


Rick Sanchez 
Level 59
Report
I think fizzer replies with the same thing everytime,
"if you don't like this game you can play something else"

I have lost hope at this point
A bold new suggestion about Clan Wars: 9/15/2021 12:49:39

Xenophon 
Level 63
Report
Clan Wars is perfect. There's no need to change anything.
A bold new suggestion about Clan Wars: 9/15/2021 12:50:05

Cicero_
Level 56
Report
@ohhhesocute and don't you think that this fact shows an obvious wrong system procedure?
A bold new suggestion about Clan Wars: 9/15/2021 12:53:22


καλλιστηι
Level 60
Report
Templates are exactly what Fizzer wants. He wants people to learn to play QM templates, he wants people in QM.
There are already people in QM.


Why would Fizzer add more strategic community templates when Gurioma and FB have been ignored for 4 months of CW?
As "ignored" as MME MA and MME commanders.
Why? Perhaps because people who play CW would want that? You can use the argument "if you don't like CW, don't play it", but the problem of this argument is, that people might listen to it.

Edited 9/15/2021 12:58:01
Posts 1 - 20 of 43   1  2  3  Next >>