Okay I'll take your word for it. Admittadly my thoughts on you are about the most unrefined. I almost didn't post a line on you but I'm a completist.

No problem. I'm glad you're being methodical; I was just curious how I earned the reputation of low activity. People usually don't tell me that ;)

Couple other bits. Kantos points out that the votes are getting split again which is not good.

Kasp voted way too early.

I am very suspicious of Kasparov. I know how he plays Mafia (sorry bud). A post or two echoing a statement every cycle, just enough to claim that you're not inactive.

I feel your inactivity, and so do others apparently. I will get to work on my list of suspects now.

Please hold off on voting yet. I agree not to all just bandwagon after the leaders, but lets atleast discuss things together before casting our unchangeable votes? We don't want a Wolf Bandwagon to topple us.

Well, we -were- told the deadline is tomorrow. Would voting minutes before the deadline be on time enough? Hehe

Please, more peolpe give suspicions. I am inclined to not vote anyone who actually gave logical suspicions here. I think most wolves are afraid to give their suspicions. Or we are simply stuck with crappy villagers.

Exactly jay. Wolves won't put together any logical suspicions. Since they already know the answers, pretending to search for them is very boring and they make mistakes that are obvious to the village.

So if everyone posts a few thoughts now we will get more info.

So jay, who did you seer last night?

I found no useful information from it, except that one guy is not an angel.

I found no useful information from it, except that one guy is not an angel.

Jeez your power is so useless

Edited 2014-09-30 20:50:11

His Balls, I PMed a VILLAGER. This resulted in the death of a WOLF.

and yes, you are totally right on one thing. Wolves will find it impossible to maintain a story of searching. That would explain all your meaningless posts. You aren't stupid. I've played with you before. You are capable of giving much more insight and advice than you have done here. Wolf.

This is gonna turn into the weidest backwards defence ever. Although I'm flattered that you somehow think I'm good at this I have no idea what that is based on.

Not sure what the first line meanes. ' I pm'd a villager...'. Please explain.

Longhouse, not useless completely. It means I am clear and can give a little bit of information (if only a tiny bit). If I get a claim that is the same as I seered a player as, I can know they are lying.

I private messaged everyone; I need to get a role claim from everyone, as well as a list of their suspects. Please do this asap. If I do not hear back from you, I will assume you are a wolf and will push for your lynching.

His Balls my accusations were based on the logic of another villager... This was confirmed by Gnuffone so I think I'm 99% innocent.

You think you are 99% innocent?

Who's the other villager?

Voting Analysis:

Players that voted for Gnuffone :

(1st time)
Apollo
Ska - Both confirmed wolves, suggests co-ordinated attack
Genghis
JSA - 99% villager
Skunk - 99% villager

(2nd time)
Apollo
Ska - Same as above, the wanted him out it seems!
Genghis (for 2nd time)
His bALLS - Championed the idea of following leadership on this/other
Dr Stupid -
Clavicus Vile
CoalEyes
Kantos
Lord Veigar
Skunk - 99% villager
Tactical Incursion - 99% villager

---

From these two votes alone, this puts the list of suspicions (via data alone) like this:

Genghis - Top

Then the rest:

His Balls,
Dr Stupid,
Clavicus Vile
Coaleyes,
Kantos,
Lord Veigar.

---

Now, to list all players and their definite wrong votes:


KANTOS -MMB, C-17, Tactical Incursion, Gnuffone, FOUR CONFIRMED VILLAGERS
Lawlz: mmb, eliza,Gnuffone
Dr Stupid: Eliza, Gnuffone, BDH
Genghis: MMB, Gnuff, Gnuff
Kasparov - MMB, Clavicus, Eliza, 3 villagers (including me), 1 wolf vote (apollo)
Apollo: - Gnuffone x2
Clavicus Vile - Tactical Incursion, Gnuffone
His Balls: Eliza, Gnuffone, NO WOLF VOTES
G.Arun: MMB, BDH
HHH: BDH and Eliza
Coal Eys: Eliza, Gnuffone, NO WOLF VOTES (was silenced alot of the time)
Frankdestlime: MMB, Many drunks
Ace Windu - SILVER, Silenced and drunk

Now my personal opinion. These are based mostly just on how I feel, not analytical data. For once i'll be keeping some things to myself since I think I have discovered some of our villager special roles.

In order of my personal suspicions:

The Kasparov Knittlewhickit
I highly suspect this young brigand. He talks just enough to claim not to be inactive whilst making subtle votes. I believe he is a wolf or somebody trying to lay low.

The Dr Stupid Dilemma
Aggressively defends himself, has been wrong quite often and posts selectively.

The Lawlz Loophole:
To me, he has appeared anti village. Whether this makes him a wolf is debatable however. I do not believe he is worth lynching at this point.

the Lord Veigar Limelight:
Pretty subtle in his posts. my general feeling puts him here.

The Kantos Kriegsgefangenenlager
I havn't really noticed him that much. His voting puts him as an outlier wolf but it's useful to remember alot of people missed votes, whilst he did not.

The Coaleyes Consideration:
I do not trust this young man in the slightest. He posts fairly selectively. He has been silenced fairly often though so not a huge suspect. Please talk more

The Frankdeestilime Farce:
Inactive, claims internet troubles. Anyone can confirm?

The HHH H
Inactive, not unusual for this player

The His Balls Hodgepodge:
Has been wrong alot, but has been consistent in his logic and often mirrors my own sentiments on things. I feel I have been manipulated however, not from His Balls, just in general. Something to consider.

The Arun Agenda:

Originally I suspected Arun. I thought his argument and sudden appearance against Apollo seemed stage. His Balls seemed to agree with me so I am likely to trust him (even if he is wrong, we've been wrong together on alot of things).

However, Arun's subsequent logic seems solid to me.

fudge I forgot Genghis.

(inbetween Kantos and Coaleyes in suspicion list)Genghis-Gate

An easy scapegoat, I believe. He voted twice for Gnuffone, but so did our confirmed villagers. After this he only voted for MMB which is debatable in significance. I have not felt a strong wolf-vibe from him but would not consider him particularly trustworthy either.

It's between his balls and Ghengis for lynching Clav. This is pretty clear; no other possibilities really.