Gnuffone's logic appears sound to me

Are you dumb. Please actually participate Arun.

Suspects:

Gnuff: Similar play to last time, doesn't get involved an awful lot. Less active due to being busy in real life -

Like he said "Is like a week i don't play a game except rt ladder (2 games). I started university (3rd year economy) and i haven't time to play." page 25.

Inactive and useless at the start of the game until mentioned - for being quiet and inactive. He defended himself a lot, slipped up a bit and said "but feel free to kill me, i am not important for the village as i am a simple villager.". Yet then he said a page later (22)

pls don't vote me, i am saying the true.
I didn0t have time to read all the post, i just read the past 15 posts.

Luckily for him. Eliza was voted over him. Then he went back to his ways (hiding!? maybe) You can see an occasional post when he just re-writes what others suspect. Like "i think shoot lalwz and lynch clav is very good." He changes his mind, when others change theirs.

3) shoot lawlz and lynch someone other. I believe Vile is really a villager. I am as well. I think we shoould lynch kantos or Kasparov.

page 32

The lastly...Once his balls said about "LYNCH ALL LURKERS!" page 33. He produces this:

here is who voted me last times:
apollo - no idea
eliza - was a villager
genghis - unknown. acted strange, and he abstain to vote 1st time.
jsa - is the idiot
Mod - very inactive. He doesn't speak.
ska2d2 - he was a wolfes
skunk - he is an elder.

I am sure not only ska2d2 voted me with the wolf role.

Here is what i think. Apollo and mod could be wolfes. Kanots as well.
I think we should vote mod as he is very inactives anyway. Otherwise i am ok with vote apollo as well.

Yet he hasn't been claimed a villager yet. Plus hes going back to pages in the 20's, when before that he was inactive and useless. Yet he accuses people that vote for him, even though this contains 2 players already Known villagers. This does not make sense.

In conclusion, Gnuff is either a wolf or has played incredible badly.

I am a villager. And i didn't played badly. I was right about ska being a wolf.

Gnuff, all you do is repeat and agree. It is a little bit useless, and suspicious, and annoying. I silence thee.

Gnuffone has been silenced.

till the day-phase end right?

Secondly, you suspect me because I suspect Viegar and then follow it up in the same post by saying that you suspect Viegar also? I don't even know where to start with that one....

I lol'ed so hard when I read that. XD

I'm not convinced Clavicus is a wolf, to be honest. I wouldn't lynch him this turn. Maybe if we could use a seer to be on the safe side?


Oh wait, we don't seem to have one anymore. . .

Timi. At the end of the game I'd love to see what you worked out.

Arun, you are gonna have to tell us exactly what was said in private between you and gnuff between 13:42 and 13:52. A dramatic change of heart. As a villager it is the worst possible thing for you to keep this information private.

Angels. Consider informing our confirmed villagers JSA, TI and skunk of your role privately. It will strengthen the alliance.

Also, Dom, although you can't regulate it is gnuff silenced only here or in all forms of communication because apparently he is fairly convincing behind the scenes.

If so we will just have to trust him to play fair.

Still awaiting JSA to say something.

don't worry i am a fair player. i will not speak at all.

I know you are. Cheers.

Gnuff only reacts to himself, that coincides with being busy. As it is now those actions would be bad wolfplay, and we already know they are quite good.

IMPORTANT: jsa (possibly others will check on my pc) may not be a confirmed villager. Yes I know this is going to make you want to Lynch me more.

If Ska was the idiot the wolves would have known that role is out of play and enable a great cover.

Just be careful. It hits me because ti and skunk are likely to follow his lead, ans we theirs.

Surely by now the real idiot would have come out seeing this claim by JSA.

Edited 2014-09-27 16:00:17

He's saying that Ska may have been the idiot before his role changed. I think that's a long shot tbh but I suppose it's worth keeping in mind.

Angels, please mail skunk, Tactical Incursions, and me.

If we get only 2 claims, we know those 2 people are the angels and we shouldn't vote them out.

I am going to start reading the last 600 posts in around 15 minutes, then will give my opinoin after that.

Gnuffone told me his reasoning which makes sense. The wolves know who is not a wolf. Therefore, they will try to bandwagon a non-wolf. Ska (wolf) voted Gnuff. Therefore more wolves surely followed suit. Apollo is the most likely wolf out of the people who voted Gnuff.

Vote Apollo

Also, notice how Apollo suddenly defends himself vehemently after he is under suspicion? This means he is a lurker - he reads but chooses to stay quiet.

Vote Apollo

I vote Apollo

To clarify the above:

Gnuffone told me his reasoning [before he was silenced]

I was only expanding on what I said previously in light of Apollo's stupid sudden appearance.