All nominated maps (including the random one) excluding the second place winner? Do they get uneligible forever?
Yes and yes.
Phakh, it's not that we dislike them, it's that none of them are good enough to be deserving of MotW. If you're asking me which ones I think are absolutely terrible, I would only say Mercer County. The others are okay. I don't hate (or really even dislike) any of the other four. But, that said, I don't believe any of them are good enough quality to deserve MotW recognition. And this has been a growing trend for the last few months, getting worse and worse as weeks go on. It's to the point now that Lionheart, NinjaNic, myself, sloppyfatginger, etc., could probably win MotW just by releasing any old mediocre map. There's no competition left in it. The winner is either the least terrible map, or, on the off chance a good map was released in the last week, that map.