A Talking Fan - Villager (now robber)
Coaleyes - Doppleganger (now 2nd seer) Claims wolf and villager in middle
GeneralGror - Drunk (now spare C)
Glen - Robber (now villager)
MightySpeck - Seer - Claims looked at middle, A is wolf,C is villager
New Luna Republic - Villager
Pulsey - ???
SirSalty - villager
Thomas 633 - Villager
Traintown - Villager

Middle - Villager
- Wolf
- ???

Role's in the game

DOPPELGANGER - Claimed
WEREWOLF 1 - ??Claimed
WEREWOLF 2 - Not in play
MINION -
SEER - Claimed
ROBBER - Claimed 1 card left not in play??
TROUBLEMAKER -
DRUNK -GeneralGror
HUNTER -
TANNER -
VILLAGER 1 -Claimed
VILLAGER 2 -Claimed
VILLAGER 3 -Not in Play

sticking with Thomas. Will not be back until game is over.

Also I bet troublemaker or villager/hunter are in spare.

Everyone be sure to vote.

For those of you who aren't aware, voting closes in 2 hours (unless Dom extends it). Time to get in any last discussion, and make sure you vote.

No one could claim he is the hunter because the hunter doesn't know his role.

Pulsey didn't say anything so he could be a wolf trying to be ignore.

I think the troublemaker is not in game because there is no point of not tell the village you are the troublemaker and who you switched.

Then New luna Republic didn't claim to be a villager but just to be team village which is very different. That could be a way to don't take to many risks. If he's a wolf and if he saw that in the spare roles there is a wolf, that didn't help him much. He was also the first one to accuse somebody else and that was with no reasons. I quote : 'Also while those statistics where intresting they look like a lot of fluff a werewolf could write to get town cred.' He could also be a minion and so doesn't have any idea of the last spare role.

So to sum up, what I actually think :
Spare roles :
-Troublemaker
-Werewolf
-Villager


Doppleganger was Coaleyes now seer
Seer : Mighty Speck (I have almost no doubts about them)
Drunk was GeneralGror now villager (If I choose to believe MightySpeck and Coaleyes there is no reason to doubt of it)
Robber was me now I'm a villager
Villager 1 was A Talking Fan now robber ( If the troublemaker is in spare role he can't be something else)
Villager 2 : Traintown (He claimed it at the very start of the game...)

All the villagers could actualy also be the hunter

I'm not sure of the end because I need Pulsey to tell us his role. I don't think he could be the tanner because the tanner cannot win without speaking. For the same reason, I don't really think his the minion because is role is to protect the wolf and that's impossible without speaking. (But if he's just innactive all that theories are just complete nonsense)
Thomas 633 in the role of tanner it's not really clever but if he's the tanner his plan is working... (I can't trust someone who start saying I'm a wolf, in fact not, I'm just a villager trying to disturb you. I was kidding, please friends don't kill me. That was a joke, just a stupid joke ! In that kind of game everyone doubt of everyone, so every single player know that kind of joke is a really really bad idea)
NewLunaRepublic as the minion could work as he's trying to make a lot of people killed but never Pulsey.
I have no reason to think that SirSalty is one of the bad roles but he didn't say much...

So for the last four roles I think that may be :
SirSalty : Villager or Hunter
NewLunaRepublic : Minion
Pulsey : Wolf (At least he spoiled the game so I have no remorse to vote against him...)
Thomas 633 : Tanner

I feel like I have to throw some more comments in somewhere, so gonna start with Glen's post and go backward and see what I get (will probably end up being more than one post, sorry bout that).

I agree that the Speck and Coaleyes combination likely are telling the truth. At least if the rule for no mailing outside of the thread is honored, because I'm pretty sure that means for team wolf too. Gror also was probably Drunk, and now villager (though it was convenient that he waited for the confirmation of roles by Coaleyes and Speck, that is the safe thing for a Drunk to do). I was a villager, and as far as I can tell wasn't switched. Glen claims the robber, and claimed who took Fan's role, but there is no way to tell the truth because Fan claimed villager before Glen said anything. I don't have any reason to doubt that Fan was a villager. Thomas does seem to be playing the role of Tanner, if very poorly...but that could also be him playing the wolf well. Salty hasn't said a whole lot, so it's difficult to come up with anything against him. Luna does seem rather accusative, and like Glen said, could be the minion, or even the wolf, though it wouldn't be the first time a villager has jumped the gun with accusations. Pulsey has literally not said a word. In fact I don't even remember him saying anything in the invite game (if anyone else remembers differently, please let me know, I can't go check apparently...). That would seem to indicate that he is not really playing, and as such couldn't be anything with an action, that is left, aka troublemaker or wolf, so he is probably just a standard villager or hunter or even tanner.

Right now my vote is wavering between Glen, Luna, and Thomas. I just have to decide who I believe and whether I think Thomas is playing the Tanner or Wolf or really is just being a bad Villager.

Villager 2 : Traintown (He claimed it at the very start of the game...)

How does claiming early prove a role?

Also due to game length an inactive and several semi-Inactives it's going to be hard to win

O sorry I rechecked and Pulsey DID say he would play on the first page, must have missed that while skimming. Still, there is no indication he has even checked this thread since that post...so what to make of that, I don't know.

Gotta say, it's hard to pick. I don't want to lose because we picked the Tanner AGAIN, and any of these claimed villagers could easily end up being the Tanner dropping subtle hints along the way. I'd almost rather lose to the wolves than pick the Tanner again...so that is kinda making me think about Glen more than Luna or Thomas...who could both be Tanners disguised as Villagers. On the other hand, I'm inclined to believe that Glen is being more truthful than either Thomas or Luna. What that actually means for roles, I'm not sure...I'm just in a bit of a conundrum.

If I'm a wolf so why the real robber didn't say anything to say I'm lying. I thing everyone agree to say spare roles are troublemaker, werewolf and villager so if I was not the robber someone could have say : Glen is lying. No one said it... Trust me or not I don't care, I'm still voting against Pulsey.

Right I was still thinking Pulsey could have been the Robber or Troublemaker, but he can't be anything that had a night role and I forgot that.

But wait...then he couldn't be the only wolf because the wolf would have to tell Dom which spare role he wanted to check...I forgot that too...

So then I'm back to either Thomas or Luna. Damn.

And I always said the truth as I'm actually a villager. And say I robbed A talking Fan who was a villager is also risky, he could have been something else such as the drunk, or the troublemaker or one of the bad role and so he could have say I was lying at that point. At that moment, if I wasn't the robber, I had no insurence of the role of A talking Fan at the beggining.

Dom asked GeneralGror to ask and never Pulsey who so could have answer him to tell him which spare role he wanted to look at.

Reason why Dom asked GeneralGror and not Pulsey because he was sure he was playing.