Dear god, MrCherry. Why do you have to be such a pessimist? Why, instead of supporting this guy who wants to make a game, do you want to engage in a debate about something so trivial? Why do you downgrade his ideas and hopes, for absolutely no benefit to yourself. Do you want him to be successful or not, because it clearly doesn't look like it.

Quit now.

Your website is out of date.

You guys don't have a clue yet.

Why are you wasting your time doing this? Did he ask you to critique his material? No! He asked you for help, not this!