<< Back to General Forum   Search

Posts 1 - 16 of 16   
Clans vs Non-Clans: 7/8/2013 15:29:17

JSA 
Level 59
Report
For a long time, people have wondered, are clan players or non-clan players better? I would like to see the top 25 of each group to be used in a competition. Each group will be randomly organized and each player in the group will play 3 games against the other group. It comes up to a total of 75 games for the competition which is an accurate number in my opinion, while nobody plays more than 3 games. I can be the clan captain, what I'll need is a non-clan captain that is a top 10 ladder level player. Is anybody interested?
Clans vs Non-Clans: 7/8/2013 15:51:51

out of coins
Level 25
Report
such a competion is senseless, everyone know that their is only one real and all-powerfull clan, and beyond The one and all-powerfull clan there is nothing
Clans vs Non-Clans: 7/8/2013 16:49:03


Ⓖ. Ⓐrun 
Level 57
Report
How will you decide the players?

Should each of the top x clan put in their best players (for votes, RRs or whatever the selection process is)?
Clans vs Non-Clans: 7/8/2013 16:52:44


[WM] Gnuffone 
Level 60
Report
How you will pick top 25 clan-members and non-clan-members?
Clans vs Non-Clans: 7/8/2013 16:53:26


[WM] Gnuffone 
Level 60
Report
i think votes in this case is bad idea, i think is much better that you pick the player.
Clans vs Non-Clans: 7/8/2013 16:55:41


myhandisonfire 
Level 54
Report
You see JSA, there is a thing about non claners you dont understand.
Independence.
The best non claners wouldnt have a captain, because they wouldnt want one.

"I want a position, give me a medal, a rank, anything please!"

In the end it would be the same people playing the same people again.
Btw the championsleague has 4 claners and 4 non claners remaining atm.
Clans vs Non-Clans: 7/8/2013 16:58:28

Seahawks 
Level 51
Report
my prediction for winner will be clanners, while there are some great non clan people (myhand, hhh, timinator, etc.) most of the best players are clan members
Clans vs Non-Clans: 7/8/2013 17:04:36

JSA 
Level 59
Report
I see non-clanners organizing teams for the Nation's Cup though. I think I would pick them by myself, maybe asking a couple other top players like Gnuffone for help on some. The problem I see with it more than anything is that there are about 4 clans with players that would be picked, maybe 5.

My idea for the top 25 (not finalized of course):

Huruey
Widzisz
JSA
Grona
Brisk
Dunga
Frankdeslimste
JUPITER
Mannerheim
Julkorn
Gnuffone
Falker
Anonymous
Old Surehand
Lobstrosity
Primary Color Movement
Tenshi
Tigger
Marc
Summer
Featherbucket
CONQUISTADORS
NoobSchool
Nich or Roo or Ineffable (2 out of the 3)

That's 6 players from just apex, 2 more that are also in another clan
3 guys from Relite
6-7 guys from [WM]
3-4 guys from [WG], 1 more that is also in another clan
1 from CPU
2 guys from AHOL, 1 more that is also in another clan
0-1 from REGL

I can't see any other clans providing anyone else who is at the level of these guys.
Clans vs Non-Clans: 7/8/2013 17:07:18


[WM] Gnuffone 
Level 60
Report
SUre. If you need of some help on pick i can help you for sure.
Template? 1v1 ladder setting?
Clans vs Non-Clans: 7/8/2013 17:07:54

Seahawks 
Level 51
Report
just to get some representation among clans i think flyingbender should participate
Clans vs Non-Clans: 7/8/2013 17:09:37


Ⓖ. Ⓐrun 
Level 57
Report
If you want better clan coverage our Prolighter division is quite strong (perhaps not as much as Apex and such but still).
Clans vs Non-Clans: 7/8/2013 17:39:44


MilitaryManiac 
Level 57
Report
Only 3 for Ahol?
Clans vs Non-Clans: 7/8/2013 17:46:52

JSA 
Level 59
Report
Military, I have thought about adding you to the list as well, you might end up on there, I can't think of anybody else from AHOL who is at a very high level though who isn't already on there. Ema and Lawm are pretty good but not at that level imo.
Clans vs Non-Clans: 7/8/2013 17:47:46

out of coins
Level 25
Report
I am happy to see that this hasnt been taken serious, otherwise it would be a waste fo time and all 25 players would have to come from relite, a few thousand if we were to include our alts
Clans vs Non-Clans: 7/8/2013 20:21:47


powerpos
Level 48
Report
Although i applaud the idea of having non-clanners play vs. clanners, i think myhand is correct, if non-clanners were interested in something like this they 'd be in a clan.
Clans vs Non-Clans: 7/8/2013 20:47:39


Timinator • apex 
Level 64
Report
All hail the mighty No-Claner-Leader!
Whoever it is and whoever would follow him *rolleyes*
Posts 1 - 16 of 16