I will vote for Arun

Myhand has been conspicuously absent from this thread recently. Come out of the shadows and let us hear what you are thinking Myhand.

I knew people usually go a bit nuts on the forums, but . . . I never thought it was this bad. Thank you all for reminding me why I try to avoid this dramatic nonsense.

That said, now we need to figure out what happens next.

I will wait for the night. Reading through all this junk and making sense of it will take time, I kind of try to avoid it for the moment.

I have to go through silver and his posts and see if they make sense in my head before i say something about. Besides, I believe the best cause of action is to reveal wolves by their voting behaviour.

So back on track. My thoughts from having read through all this only once. Note all the players I have omitted who barely have a profile in the game.

There are so many players who randomly followed my MoD vote. I cant believe no one is questioning that? Apollo? bdh? Kasperov? There are 7 more which I cant be bothered to dig out. Ten is a lot. There are wolves lost in that pack.

Why did the wolves kill Pulsey? Just because?

There are some players who I think you need to kill Dom who are just too inactive for this game to work. some also look a bit alt like to me.

G. Arun - dunno - could be - I just want him dead
Skunk would be another choice of someone who seems trustworthy and level headed like Myhand.
MysteryManBall - is not a wolf, Im sure
Veigar- 'go with the flow' genuinely this is one of the most obvious tells in this game.
Ska - just going with Windus theory - the theory was so weak.
Riyamitie - might be the muuse? surely didn't make that mistake?

Off the top of my head some thoughts. Hopefully it will get you started agin properly.

Edited 8/28/2014 17:26:02

Can we take this opportunity (Silver retiring) to go back to the spirit of the game?

Which I do not believe PM's are a part of.

kalira gives good advice on how we should be playing - even if Dom has allowed loopholes there's no need to be gamey.

EDIT: His balls you underestimate how long it takes me to get up in the morning and my cognitive abilities pre - tea and cigarette, but I won't stoop to "It's not me waa waa's". That's for you all to decide ... that's the game :)

Edited 8/28/2014 17:28:12

I just realized the night is over. Pulsey was killed relieving himself instead of standing guard.
Typical him. If he hadnt been eaten by the wolves, we had lynched him for leaving his post.

So, how much time do we have before we need to make up our votes?

Edited 8/28/2014 17:31:14

Silver could be still playing the game and all that about retiring could be a work.

I guess it wont be till tomorrow myhand.

This is what I posted several pages back just after the first night ended:

Ghenghis and Apollo voted for Pulsey. This could be just because of Pulsey's reputation or it could be they are wolves and knew he was a villager.

bdh1998 cast the 3rd vote for MoD and Kasparov the 4th. These votes took MoD well into the lead as before that there were 2 votes for MoD, 2 for Pulsey and 1 for MysteryMan.
Arun followed suit and cast the fifth vote against MoD with Ska casting the 6th. MysteryMan cast the seventh, most likely for self preservation.

I voted Arun because I believe Silver.

I shall have faith in Silver

I vote ARUN

(I cannot type in fomt but in capitals)

Suspicion based on what people say is not very reliable (yet).
What is very reliable, is examining who jumped on the bandwagon of killing MoD instead of Mysteryman.

MoD came out asking for a vote on killing Mysterman. We know now that MoD was a villager. When killing in the dark , killing mysterman is somewhat reasonable (no offense mysteryman, we still like you).

noballs was the first to iniate a turnaround against MoD, without any explanation, this is why i believe we need to vote him.
In some later posts of him he claimed me to be trustworthy, which doesnt mean anything, it could just mean he wants to buy my vote (or other villagers votes) by evelating me above suspicion.

G. Arun - dunno - could be - I just want him dead
Skunk would be another choice of someone who seems trustworthy and level headed like Myhand.
MysteryManBall - is not a wolf, Im sure
Veigar- 'go with the flow' genuinely this is one of the most obvious tells in this game.
Ska - just going with Windus theory - the theory was so weak.
Riyamitie - might be the muuse? surely didn't make that mistake?

Much of this bollocks. Declaring MysteryMan not being a wolf is ridiculous. How can you have that insight?
Declaring Riyamitie a muse is even more ridiculous. The muse role is about the hardest to tell out of every character, what made you come up with this?

Our primar suspects are

Ace Windu has voted for MoD

bdh1998 has voted for MoD
Blue has voted for MoD
Ehrmantraut has voted for MoD

G. Arun has voted for MoD


Hermes has voted for Silver
his balls. has voted for MoD
Kasparov has voted for MoD

Lord Veigar has voted for MoD


MysteryMan has voted for MoD


Riyamitie has voted for MoD

Ska2D2 has voted for MoD


They all vote for MoD. I included Hermes in the list, since he newly joined and wasted his vote instead of adding it to someone polarized.
What we know for sure is that from the 3 guys that joined late, Gnuff, Hermes and Phulesdrop one is a wolf to not upset game balance.

I believe it to be Hermes, for deviating his vote into the void.

Riyamite gave his vote very late and with a flimsy explanation attached. Maybe some sort of guilt conscience.

Now AceWindu is still on the list , but he shouldnt. He tried to change his vote to someone else and he gave out some logical explanations throughout the thread. More logical than hisballs assumptions for sure.

So what we need to do now, is to argue which of guys we kill on the list.

I want to hear arguments!

What we know for sure is that from the 3 guys that joined late, Gnuff, Hermes and Phulesdrop one is a wolf to not upset game balance.

i am not so sure about this. Dom say he planned to add some player after the start. It could also be, he add 2 wolf, or no wolf. Assume thing bc dom would make balanced team isn't smart IMO.

Suspicion based on what people say is not very reliable (yet).
What is very reliable, is examining who jumped on the bandwagon of killing MoD instead of Mysteryman.

MoD came out asking for a vote on killing Mysterman. We know now that MoD was a villager. When killing in the dark , killing mysterman is somewhat reasonable (no offense mysteryman, we still like you).

noballs was the first to iniate a turnaround against MoD, without any explanation, this is why i believe we need to vote him.
In some later posts of him he claimed me to be trustworthy, which doesnt mean anything, it could just mean he wants to buy my vote (or other villagers votes) by evelating me above suspicion.


G. Arun - dunno - could be - I just want him dead
Skunk would be another choice of someone who seems trustworthy and level headed like Myhand.
MysteryManBall - is not a wolf, Im sure
Veigar- 'go with the flow' genuinely this is one of the most obvious tells in this game.
Ska - just going with Windus theory - the theory was so weak.
Riyamitie - might be the muuse? surely didn't make that mistake?


Much of this bollocks. Declaring MysteryMan not being a wolf is ridiculous. How can you have that insight?
Declaring Riyamitie a muse is even more ridiculous. The muse role is about the hardest to tell out of every character, what made you come up with this?

Our primar suspects are

Ace Windu has voted for MoD

bdh1998 has voted for MoD
Blue has voted for MoD
Ehrmantraut has voted for MoD

G. Arun has voted for MoD


Hermes has voted for Silver
his balls. has voted for MoD
Kasparov has voted for MoD

Lord Veigar has voted for MoD


MysteryMan has voted for MoD


Riyamitie has voted for MoD

Ska2D2 has voted for MoD


They all vote for MoD. I included Hermes in the list, since he newly joined and wasted his vote instead of adding it to someone polarized.
What we know for sure is that from the 3 guys that joined late, Gnuff, Hermes and Phulesdrop one is a wolf to not upset game balance.

I believe it to be Hermes, for deviating his vote into the void.

Riyamite gave his vote very late and with a flimsy explanation attached. Maybe some sort of guilt conscience.

Now AceWindu is still on the list , but he shouldnt. He tried to change his vote to someone else and he gave out some logical explanations throughout the thread. More logical than hisballs assumptions for sure.

So what we need to do now, is to argue which of guys we kill on the list.

I want to hear arguments!

I actually disagree with myhand. The fact that he posted this list without including a few of the people I have the most suspicions about makes me think he's a wolf, attempting to shift suspicion away from the wolves. The above list is propaganda, and is unlikely to include any of the wolves at all.

I'm on the blacklist woot should be interesting. But I'm still allowed to vote even if the gestapo is watching me ;)

I'm leaning towards His balls, because of the change in his character from the two games. There is more inconsistency about him recently. Though in his defence I guess he did say that defending yourself can often mean digging a deeper hole.

The His Balls v Arun battle would be a shame to finish early though ...

adding 2 wolves would completely upset the game balance.

Wolves must be W = √V
V being the villagers.

Otherwise it would mess up game balance. Since I believe Dom knows what he is doing, I believe this is a fair assumption.

@Kasparov It would be awesome if myhand was a wolf. Just to see what he could pull of linguistically :)

Also the thought had crossed my mind ... but i think this game makes you consider everyone and like I said in my second post. Especially those who take part the most. Which is what everyone should do otherwise why are you playing?

Yeah Ska2D2, good point. I kind of wish myself I was a wolf now :)

I really appreciate the post of Kasparov. He fails to see the reasoning in my post, adds a flimsy explanation and agitates against me. Good polarization. We will need that for the future.

I think he should be among the primary suspects of our suspects.

Edited 8/28/2014 18:24:53

I wanted to shoot his balls. and myhandisonfire tonight.
I wanted to lynch Lord Veigar today.

I had convincing cases against all of them, but now seeing how little appreciated the effort I've put into the game so far is (oh yes, it has been crazy time consuming, that's actually the main reason I chose to self-destruct) I'm not going to waste more time explaining why exactly.

I just threw Arun under the bus for being a nuisance with his morals and whatnot on skype.

What? I can talk I'm not dead yet. :D

among the primary suspects of our suspects...?

Okay, then.

Hmmm now thanks to your post i have to lower my suspicion on hisballs, silver. Let me hear about your convincing case against me. I really want to hear it.

Given that you directed your suspicion against me so confidentely, I must now assume you are a clear wolf. No more hiding behind ignorant and hybristic errors anymore.

Edited 8/28/2014 18:29:38