In my last game

http://warlight.net/MultiPlayer?GameID=5185279

some things seems very strange.
One player http://warlight.net/Profile?p=6524648136 was wasting his most troops
for nothing instead to get the save neutral bonus. I cant imagine that he is really
going for this, cause in this early stage he had normally to deal with several enemies.

But the real evidence for me is, when the guy who controlled his puppet,
built up a stack for 5 rounds and don't attack his puppet.
He booted him right after he got useless. Also the puppetstats are interesting:
only won 2 out 55 and 45%bootrate.

In my opinion this case is clear. But maybe there is little chance that i got crazy ;)
and he is only one hardcore noob? So what do you guys think? Worth a report or only my craziness?

Are you sure you are talking about Nickboer? There doesn`t really seems to be anything wrong imo, could you points out the moments you thought were weird?

His crazy moves were on turn 3 where he gives a 100% bonus away.
Than killed with his puppetmaster an enemy in round 8 and waited
for him to stack up until round 15.

Xenor, you overlooked something. Nick was building troops in his bonus. He knew he couldn't get that 8 Scamster bonus so he deployed on his little 3 bonus and was going to prepare a trap for blue to run into. Imo, that's his best move. I think he realized he lost and just walked away from the game.

Why then blue waited over 5 turns to attack,
cause he had the big stack advantage and nothing to lose?

He didn't exactly wait, as he was expanding other places. He also knew that green wasn't close to winning due to the spy card. when he was completely locked in he began ataccing, I think this is actually well played.

Also he, he did actually have something to lose- his stack. additionally what did he have to gain by ataccing earlier? not much.

Thanks for your opinions guys ;)

A lot of strange circumstances, the waiting, the boot, useless stackbuilding,
but you convienced me, that some crazy moves from two players, that i never will
understand, can happen. So the case is closed: in dubio pro reo!

Edited 11/19/2013 23:28:51

Yeah sure, he was kinda timid, but he could tell by the deploys that his opponent was building up behind a border somewhere so why risk it when you don't really know his income for sure? The stackbuilding wasn't useless, and it didn't really give blue a big advantage. (shrug)