The Long-Awaited Second Clan League Results: 5/18/2013 12:53:09 |
Jacob the Fearless
Level 2
Report
|
The settings for the games are good I think, but this season lasted too long and had too many games. I think with only 5 teams in a division, the teams could possibly add more tournaments or less depending on how many players they have, and it could be shorter and less games for everyone. I am starting to think about groups for teams, I will probably start asking about Group A's lineups today or tommorrow and then go to other divisions after that.
|
The Long-Awaited Second Clan League Results: 5/18/2013 15:42:13 |
JSA
Level 60
Report
|
My personal thinking for most of the groups at the moment:
Group A:
[WM]
Apex
AHOL
[WG]
Relite
I have a hard time putting any clans above them.
Group B:
[WL]
CPU
[REGL]
{Warlighters}
[VIW]
Group C:
FBG
[MC]
{101st}
[TUC]
Dragon
After that it comes down to which clans have the people to compete and whether there are any new ones.
|
The Long-Awaited Second Clan League Results: 5/18/2013 15:58:26 |
JSA
Level 60
Report
|
Arun, I did it mostly compared to last season. But when you look at the people last season, it seems much more obvious to do it this way. Relite is obviously deserving of Group A. [WG] had 4 people in it at that time, one of which was booted in over half of his games. CPU finished 2 points above [WG] but lost Ineffable to [WG] and did not gain many good players that I know of. [WL] was carried by Ironnova who won his 1v1 and 2v2 tournaments. He is no longer active, so that is their best player gone. 2 other members that participated for that clan are also now inactive.
Gnuffone, I'm not sure, hopefully within the next couple weeks, maybe even sooner. I think that the template works well enough. However since in the top group, each clan has at least 10 or so players I believe, I will make a game with the leaders of the clans and we might add a few more tournaments to give more players a shot to do whatever they want.
|
The Long-Awaited Second Clan League Results: 5/20/2013 20:21:39 |
[WM] ᵀᴴᴱ𝓕𝓻𝓲𝓭𝓰𝓮
Level 60
Report
|
Despite i believe for example WG and ReLite definitely belong to GroupA, i think if you make divisions this season, the ONLY acceptable way is by dividing according to results of last season. There should not be any bias or handicap based on your whim, even when most of people agree some clans seem better than others. If you divide this into groups, then it should be done like in promotion/relegaiton league. Group divisions should be decided only on standings from last seasons, and new participants should start from the bottom. and i also agree 5 is a bit to few. it should be somewhere between 7 and 10 clans for each group..
let's be fair JSA, let it be something like:
A)
1. Apex/[WM]: 176
2. Apex/[WM]: 176
3. AHOL: 163
4. [WL]: 157
5. CPU: 129
6. [WG]: 127
7. [REGL]: 116
B)
8. {Warlighters}: 108
9. FBG: 106
10. [VIW]/[MC]: 105
11. [VIW]/[MC]: 105
12. {RSP}: 88
13. {101st}: 75
14. [TUC]: 66
C)
15. Dragon: 58
16. [KK]: 51
17. Elite: 37
18. [P]/[Zen-D]: 36
19. [P]/[Zen-D]: 36
20. {RING}: 30
if people demand it, i would give a wildcard to ReLites into group B or A, but it's a slippery idea, because if they get a wildcard, then why don't the others..? The more subjective you will get and the more clans you will treat individually, the less arbitrary and serious this league will be. I do understand some clans had retirements in their teams, and some boots as well.. but for example WM had the same problem with at least one player, which cost us a few points. But we don't whine about it.
|
Post a reply to this thread
Before posting, please proofread to ensure your post uses proper grammar and is free of spelling mistakes or typos.
|
|