i think that Robber and seer are at least two of the spare roles. (might change after skunk actually tells us what he is)

with maybe Werewolf and Minion?

or*

There could just as easily be 3 wolves pretending to be villagers, and villagers in the spares.

O.O

well. i guess we just have to wait for genghis

I am quite busy but that was just a mistake. Hopefully I didn't affect anyones night actions. Apologies.

I have to go again now but will look in a bit.

I'm back now and I have updated the graph.

https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1bBKALE0oCiqeh5c8jUyxedovw_wRcwxhxX_NX_oaMFE/edit#gid=0

Still waiting on Genghis.

Saying robber and seer are in the pile then there must be at least 2 wolves/minion and wolf out there.

Skunk was hopefully the seer.

I believe his balls saying he is a villager. If he was a more important role he'd probably put more effort in, unless VERY busy.

I believe Coaleyes was the Tanner. Has no reason to lie

Forbidden Knowledge seems most likely to be on team wolf so far. Boredom is such a boring answer.

Skunk is now Tanner and we know it. No reason to lie about past role. just waiting for more info

Traintown is also a possible wolf. He puts suspicion on his balls and speck without much reason, also on FK. Although he jumps on people very fast, (considering last game) this just seems to be his normal behaviour. His analysis of FK is fair in my opinion. Doesn't clear him, though.

Mighty Speck - ignored the accusations against him. Pins wolf role on Genghis for no reason. Can't tell if dumb or wolfish.

I agree with Coaleyes. It seems there are a few special villager roles in the spares. If so, there are wolves prowling our ranks.

want to hear more from Thomas633 and Genghis. mystery man could contribute something too eh. Keep us entertained ;)

I didn't respond to the accusation because i saw it as a valid conclusion and had no prove to prove myself. and my reasoning for Genghis is that it's been forever and he hasn't responded. if Genghis gives some valid prove I will change my vote. but for know i think he is the Werewolf.

and Genghis was on 10 hours ago.

Fair enough. But we have no reason not to believe Genghis' Doppelgänger claim. Perhaps he is also waiting for more information before telling us his night actions.

What do you think about FK, Thomas or Traintown?

Fair enough. But we have no reason not to believe Genghis' Doppelgänger claim. Perhaps he is also waiting for more information before telling us his night actions.

What do you think about FK, Thomas or Traintown?

Thomas last seen 4 hours ago so by that logic he should be the one to vote for

We have no reason to believe his claims either.

I Imagine Thomas probably just ins't putting that much effort into the game. or he could be staying quiet so we don't think of him.

FK could just have no idea what is going on (because he already doesn't have time to pick picks) but more likely he has no idea what his role is. or he could just be lying.

Traintown's activity seems normal. although maybe he wants to talk a lot and make everyone Suspicious so he doesn't himself.

That's true my dear Skunk. I'm anxious to hear what he has to say.

Dangit. Sometimes I hate this auto-refresh thing...

I do not believe FK was the drunk. Even if he was burned out in the last game, it still doesn't make sense to outright say you are the drunk, and after all, he did accept the invitation to the game. However, what his true role was eludes me, though at this point I would wager Coaleyes was indeed the tanner, making FK on team wolf by default.